The colour is really good. But its not smudge free or transfer proof which must be noted becayse it tends to spread all over your coffee mug , spoon even if your hands if you accidently touch your lips. Even a slight touch can transfer/smudge the shade. Top it up with a transfer proof coating or something . Also maybe since its so creamy , the product came out of the stick the next day! But you can fix it. Still feels somewhat difficult to use. Read more